Puppy Passports
Home
PLANNING FOR A PUP
  • Choosing pet services
  • Veterinarian prep
  • Groomer prep
  • Dog body language
  • Consent to pet
  • Bringing home a new pup
  • Walking gear
  • Feeding your dog
  • Pups and kids
  • When do I correct?
  • Introducing to pets
UNDER 8 MOS
  • Socialization
  • Potty training
  • Dog Body Language
  • Exercise / Activity
  • Chewing / Teething
  • Mouthing / Biting
  • Attention driven behavior
  • Crating / Confinement
  • Training to be alone
  • Resource guarding
  • When do I correct
  • Pups and kids
OVER 8 MOS
  • Socialization 2.0
  • Potty training
  • Dog body language
  • Exercise / Activity 2.0
  • Attention driven behavior
  • Mouthing/Biting
  • Inappropriate chewing
  • Crating / Confinement 2.0
  • Training to be alone 2.0
  • Resource guarding
  • When do I correct?
  • Pups and kids
Puppy Passports
Home
PLANNING FOR A PUP
  • Choosing pet services
  • Veterinarian prep
  • Groomer prep
  • Dog body language
  • Consent to pet
  • Bringing home a new pup
  • Walking gear
  • Feeding your dog
  • Pups and kids
  • When do I correct?
  • Introducing to pets
UNDER 8 MOS
  • Socialization
  • Potty training
  • Dog Body Language
  • Exercise / Activity
  • Chewing / Teething
  • Mouthing / Biting
  • Attention driven behavior
  • Crating / Confinement
  • Training to be alone
  • Resource guarding
  • When do I correct
  • Pups and kids
OVER 8 MOS
  • Socialization 2.0
  • Potty training
  • Dog body language
  • Exercise / Activity 2.0
  • Attention driven behavior
  • Mouthing/Biting
  • Inappropriate chewing
  • Crating / Confinement 2.0
  • Training to be alone 2.0
  • Resource guarding
  • When do I correct?
  • Pups and kids
More
  • Home
  • PLANNING FOR A PUP
    • Choosing pet services
    • Veterinarian prep
    • Groomer prep
    • Dog body language
    • Consent to pet
    • Bringing home a new pup
    • Walking gear
    • Feeding your dog
    • Pups and kids
    • When do I correct?
    • Introducing to pets
  • UNDER 8 MOS
    • Socialization
    • Potty training
    • Dog Body Language
    • Exercise / Activity
    • Chewing / Teething
    • Mouthing / Biting
    • Attention driven behavior
    • Crating / Confinement
    • Training to be alone
    • Resource guarding
    • When do I correct
    • Pups and kids
  • OVER 8 MOS
    • Socialization 2.0
    • Potty training
    • Dog body language
    • Exercise / Activity 2.0
    • Attention driven behavior
    • Mouthing/Biting
    • Inappropriate chewing
    • Crating / Confinement 2.0
    • Training to be alone 2.0
    • Resource guarding
    • When do I correct?
    • Pups and kids
  • Home
  • PLANNING FOR A PUP
    • Choosing pet services
    • Veterinarian prep
    • Groomer prep
    • Dog body language
    • Consent to pet
    • Bringing home a new pup
    • Walking gear
    • Feeding your dog
    • Pups and kids
    • When do I correct?
    • Introducing to pets
  • UNDER 8 MOS
    • Socialization
    • Potty training
    • Dog Body Language
    • Exercise / Activity
    • Chewing / Teething
    • Mouthing / Biting
    • Attention driven behavior
    • Crating / Confinement
    • Training to be alone
    • Resource guarding
    • When do I correct
    • Pups and kids
  • OVER 8 MOS
    • Socialization 2.0
    • Potty training
    • Dog body language
    • Exercise / Activity 2.0
    • Attention driven behavior
    • Mouthing/Biting
    • Inappropriate chewing
    • Crating / Confinement 2.0
    • Training to be alone 2.0
    • Resource guarding
    • When do I correct?
    • Pups and kids

Correcting behavior

When do you need to correct your dog's behavior?  The simple answer is that you do not need to use correction or punishment as a strategy in teaching your dog how you would like them to behave.  


Punishment of behavior can work – the problem is that the intensity required to make the punisher effective works because it causes the dog to feel uncomfortable, and may cause frustration, pain or fear. When punishment is delayed or inconsistent it makes you scary and unpredictable.  At best, this breaks down the positive social relationship between you and your dog.  At worst it can cause or exacerbate negative emotional states - displayed as fear, shutting down, avoidance or aggression. Punishment can result in physical and psychological injury to the dog, and trigger bites to people and dogs. 


The evidence supporting the use of positive reinforcement and rewards based training methods is overwhelming.  The certifying bodies for dog behavior professionals are now requiring their members to adhere to the principles of the Least Intrusive Minimally Aversive (LIMA) framework as the minimum standard for the field.  

Problems in punishment 101

  • If your dog is doing something you feel is inappropriate, they may not understand how you would like them to behave.  They are making the best choice they can.  They may also be experiencing fear or frustration that is making it challenging for them to make a good choice even if they do understand what you expect. 


  • At the point things are not going as planned, you cannot be concerned with what is being reinforced, the goal should be to quickly interrupt the behavior with the least force possible, and if needed increase distance, decrease intensity of the trigger or remove your dog from the situation causing the unwanted behavior. Moving forward, set your dog up for success and if needed reach out to a behavior professional to help you address the behavior.


  • While it is tempting to correct aggressive behavior, punishing them for these behaviors can suppress their warning system: growling, snarling, snapping. This can cause dog's communication system to deteriorate, limiting their ability to communicate effectively and negotiate situations on their own.  When they are unable to safely give warnings, they may escalate to biting and it will seem like it comes from 'out of the blue'. 

Myth Busting: Punishment

  • Dogs practicing these behaviors are not trying to be the leader or dominate you, they are unable to cope and need your help to learn they can choose a different behavior.


  • Attempts to correct behaviors ultimately give the dog attention (yelling, squirting, pushing them off) and may further reinforce the behavior. 


  • Dogs do not need you to show them who is boss, be a ‘pack leader’ or dominate them. Set them up for success and be sure they find preferred behaviors rewarding reliably. 


  • Dogs continue to learn throughout their life, old dogs can learn new tricks. It may take them some time to learn how to respond differently when they have practiced a behavior you don’t prefer for a long time, but the majority of behavior concerns can be modified.  That said, it will be easier if you are proactive.


  • Positive reinforcement does not mean you must be permissive.  Good management and removing them from a situation that is too challenging for them to display appropriate behavior is best.

 

  • Allowing a dog to sleep in the bed or get on the furniture is ok, as long as you are comfortable allowing it and there are not behavior concerns related to being approached/touched while in a preferred spot.

Resources: Avoiding punishment

AVSAB Humane Dog Training

AVSAB Dominance Theory

LIMA FAQ from APDT

LIMA overview from CCPDT

Puppy Passports Index

Puppy Passports Index

Puppy Passports Index

There's so much more to learn to understand your pup. Check out more great articles here! 

ARTICLE INDEX

Need more support?

Puppy Passports Index

Puppy Passports Index

Gigi's Behavior Services has behavior pros that can support you in our facility, at home, and remotely via Zoom. 

MORE SUPPORT

Copyright © 2023 Gigi's - All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept